Skip to content 
Before I ever advise a client to make an offer on a property, there’s a specific, consistent set of factors running through my evaluation.
I’m with Coldwell Banker in Studio City, and I’ve lived in Sherman Oaks for over thirty years. The tools have changed in that time. The basic questions have not: Is the price supported, is the house what it appears to be, and does it still feel right after the first burst of excitement has faded?
What Data Should You Check Before Making an Offer on a House?
Start with three things: recent comparable sales, the real physical condition of the house, and how long it has been on the market. Together they give an objective foundation for any offer. None of them works alone, and each needs context before it turns into a number you are willing to sign.
On the price, I want to see recent closed sales that are genuinely comparable — similar location, similar lot, similar condition — not just a handful of active listings with a similar bedroom count. On condition, I look at what is visible and what will need a closer look: the roof, the systems, signs of water or movement, obvious unpermitted work, and any major systems that are near the end of their useful life.
Time on the market matters too, but only in context. A house that has been sitting may be overpriced, or it may have a condition or location issue we need to understand. A house that just came on the market may be fairly priced, or it may be testing a high number. The data is the starting point, not the entire decision.
Why Does a Second Visit Matter Before Making an Offer?
Because the first visit is mostly excitement. On a second visit, ideally at a different time of day, buyers notice light, noise, traffic, and the rooms that feel smaller than they remembered. That calmer reaction often reveals something data alone cannot capture, and it belongs in the conversation before any offer.
I like that second visit to happen at a different time of day, when possible. Light changes. Street noise changes. Parking and traffic look different at 8:30 in the morning than they do on a quiet afternoon. A house that felt perfect at twilight should also be asked to show itself on an ordinary weekday.
I also listen for the comments that come after the showing, on the drive away, when the staging and the first impression have had a few minutes to fade. People are often more precise then. They will mention the room that felt small, the street that felt busier than expected, or the part of the house they already want to change. Those observations are useful, and they belong in the conversation before an offer is written.
What If the Numbers and Your Gut Reaction Disagree?
Slow down and name the discrepancy. A house that looks great on paper but feels wrong on a second visit deserves scrutiny, and one that feels right but fails the data deserves caution. After three decades in this business, I trust the combination far more than either signal on its own.
When the two sides disagree, I do not rush to break the tie. Sometimes the data is pointing to a problem we can investigate — a pricing issue, a condition concern, or a comparable sale we had not fully considered. Sometimes the hesitation is about lifestyle, and a third visit or a closer look at the daily routine is the right next step. The point is to name the discrepancy clearly, rather than hoping it will disappear once the offer is in.
When Is a Buyer Ready to Make an Offer?
When strong comparable data and a sustained positive reaction line up. By then we have reviewed the numbers and obvious condition issues, toured at least twice, and compared the house with the others we have seen. Only after that do we talk about the specific terms of an offer.
There is also a practical sequence I like to follow. First we look at the numbers and the obvious condition issues. Then we tour, and then we tour again if the house is still in the running. Only after that do I want to talk about the specific terms of an offer. When those steps get reversed — when a buyer wants to write an offer off a first walk-through, or off a set of photographs — I slow the process down. A major purchase deserves a little more air than that.
I also pay attention to how a house compares with the others we have already seen. A property can feel wonderful in isolation and then feel like a compromise once you put it next to a stronger lot, a quieter street, or a better floor plan. That comparison is part of the evaluation, and it is one more reason I do not like to rush the first burst of enthusiasm into a signature.
Moving forward still means doing the remaining homework. Disclosures, inspections, and a clear plan for the offer terms all come next. My advice to write an offer is not a promise that the house is perfect. It is a judgment that the price, the property, and your reaction to it are strong enough to take the next serious step.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many times should a buyer visit a property before making an offer?
At least twice, ideally at different times of day, is generally advisable for any significant purchase, particularly at the luxury level. If a second visit is not possible, I want to be especially careful about what we still do not know.
What if the data and the emotional reaction genuinely conflict?
This is worth discussing explicitly and honestly — sometimes it reveals a specific concern worth addressing directly with the seller or through further inspection. I would rather pause than paper over a doubt that is still going to be there after closing.
Does this approach apply to investment properties as well as primary residences?
The emotional component matters less for a pure investment property, where data-driven analysis should generally take clear precedence. Even then, a second look at condition and location is still time well spent. Rent, vacancy, and upkeep costs should drive the decision.
Ready to Apply This to Your Own Search?
What would you want your agent checking before you made a major offer like this? I’m glad to walk through this exact process with you when you’re ready to make an offer.
David Hitt · Broker Associate, CLHMS · Coldwell Banker Realty · DRE #01210537 · 818-422-1702 · David@DavidHitt.com
